Archive Articles

School Owners Beware! New Government Regulations Could Force You to Close Your School

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, May 2009 (pages 39–41). See the full issue.

The battle lines have been drawn in Texas—and the fight is likely to come to your state and your front door—so now’s the time to act. In fact, Charles Dudley, NAPMA Inner Circle Member and owner of Kung Jung Mu Sul in San Antonio, Texas, has been leading the fight against the Texas legislature and various state regulatory bodies, since 2000. As the battle intensifies, he is devoting 80 hours a week to save the industry in Texas.

It’s time all NAPMA members and school owners throughout the industry rally around Master Dudley and his many local supporters, and tell Texas state legislators and administrators to support Texas State House Bill 1393…because your state and your school could be next! NAPMA has created a special Web page, so you can quickly and easily customize and send a letter via email to Texas state officials. Visit NAPMA.com/TexasLaw for more information. “I’d like to think that state legislators, in general, mean well, and don’t want to interfere in the lives and businessesoftheirconstituenciesanymore than necessary. Sometimes, however, they incorrectly lump various industries together, which may share some common components. Those legislators require more understanding of those industries, including martial arts, before they can write fair and equitable legislation,” said Dudley. “I believe the core issue is allowing parents to be free to choose the activities in which they want their children to participate,” he added. Some legislators and state officials could cause (presumably) unintended and dire consequences for martial arts schools in Texas if current pending legislation is passed, which would define martial arts schools as daycare facilities.

According to one piece of legislation, ‘Daycare center means a childcare facility that provides care at a location other than the residence of the director, owner, or operator of the child-care facility for seven or more children younger than 14 years of age for less than 24 hours a day, but at least two hours a day, three or more days a week.’

Another pending bill reads, ‘Afterschool program means a child-care facility that provides care before and after the customary school day and during school holidays, for at least two hours a day, three days a week to children who attend pre-kindergarten through grade six.’ “Many martial arts students spend about that much time in class,” said Dudley. “If we become licensed daycare facilities, then we can no longer practice martial arts because state law doesn’t allow weapons or sparring activities in a daycare; and that’s just one example of why this legislation would close our doors.” According to Dudley, this clearly indicates that state legislators and those charged with enforcing Texas daycare regulations simply don’t understand the martial arts industry and how, in their zeal to protect the INDUSTRY ALERT School Owners Beware!

New Government

Regulations Could Force you To Close your School

public and demonstrate their leadership, they are destroying an industry that provides many benefits for citizens of the state.

Fighting on Multiple Fronts

The fight would be much easier if it was just a matter of educating legislators to understand and have more respect for the martial arts industry; but Dudley says he and his supporters must also fight the money interests, such as the Texas Licensed Child Care Association (TLCCA), and seemingly unsympathetic state agencies, such as the Department of Family Protective Services (DFPS). “The DFPS is legally required to enforce daycare facilities rules that don’t apply to martial arts schools,” said Dudley. “In fact, the department is planning to force all youth sports programs to be designated as daycares, so it could regulate those activities, as well. “The DFPS agents don’t understand martial arts, so it’s difficult for them to do their jobs. While this legislation is currently pending, however, they have been told to cease and desist forcing martial arts school owners to submit to the daycare regulations. “We’ve had to be vigilant in our constant fight against the DFPS’ tactics, which have included threats, injunctions, closed schools, etc; but we’ve fought them a number of ways, including court cases. To stop those tactics, we’ve had to turn to a legislative solution,” added Dudley. Dudley claims that the DFPS has been applying the current daycare regulations, according to its interpretation of the law, and has also been writing rules outside those laws, all in an effort to target martial arts schools. “The DFPS complicated the situation even further by providing some exceptions to the rules they’ve been applying to entice/force martial arts schools into becoming licensed daycare facilities,” said Dudley. “During July 2008, the State Attorney General ruled, because of court cases I have been arguing for years, that the DFPS doesn’t have the statutory authority to exempt its rules and that it has been writing rules that are not backed by statue. This has created a real mess. Now, there are martial arts schools throughout Texas committing crimes, as a result.” “The TLCCA’s objective is very obvious, since it’s listed on its Web site,” said Dudley. “It wants the current legislation to be passed, so skills-training and summer camp facilities can be controlled by those new statues. With fewer skills-training operations, such as independent martial arts schools, more kids would be forced to find that training at TLCCA-member facilities.”

Dudley has also discovered that many daycare centers have added martial arts classes, and promoting that training as the equivalent of a martial arts school, which are the only facilities with the skilled and experienced staff to provide students with comprehensive training, and for the long-term. “The new legislation even affects summer camps. The current rules, again, not backed by statue, make it impossible to obtain a license to operate a martial arts summer camp,” said Dudley. “I operated a camp program every summer for years, until 2005, when I could not obtain a license. “I’m not against responsible regulations;Ijustwantpropergovernment oversight for martial arts schools that still protects children, and allows us to run our businesses as we see fit.” That’s why support of House Bill 1393 is so important because its language treats martial arts schools correctly and fairly. You can show your support by visiting NAPMA.com/TexasLaw and sending a letter to Texas state legislators and administrators. Press Time Update Breaking News!

As this issue of Martial Arts Professional goes to press, Charles Dudley reports that the Texas legislative process is moving forward quickly. He has been able to persuade key legislators and the Governor of Texas to support the various bills and their amendments that are adversely affecting the martial arts industry. “SB 68 is expected to go to the floor of the Senate tomorrow (early April) to be debated, and then a vote is to be called. I have issued a letter to all the senators that the martial arts industry in Texas now supports SB 68 with the amended changes,” said Dudley. “The House hearing on HB 1393 is also tomorrow. It will be changed slightly, but probably will be stuck in committee. We totally support this bill. The end result should be a total exemption for all skill-based programs, which includes martial arts schools.” “ The DFPS is legally required to enforce daycare facilities rules that don’t apply to martial arts schools.” INDUSTRY ALERT

The Olympic Gymnastics Angle

Dudley wants the martial arts industry to know that gymnastics academies, dance studios, cheerleader programs, and even youth hockey leagues, have joined him in this effort to save everyone’s business. Gymnastics is a very popular activity for children in Texas; and a great part of that popularity can be attributed to the fact that Texas produces more Olympic athletes than any other state in the U.S. Since gymnastics students train for as much as 30 to 40 hours per week, those programs would also be negatively affected by this legislation and the scrutiny of the DFPS. “Gymnastics students are injured as part of their training, and we want to make sure those children are adequately protected,” said Dudley. “On theotherhand,duringtherecentSenate hearing, testimony revealed that 12 children died in licensed childcare facilities in the state of Texas during 2008, but we couldn’t find any deaths in gymnastics, or martial arts.” “I want to thank Diane Callison, the Texas chairman of USA Gymnastics. We would have never made so much progress without her help,” added Dudley.

The Path to a Positive Outcome

Dudley said Senate Bill 68 (the bad bill) and House Bill 1393 are now grinding slowly through the legislative machinery. It will be passed back and forth from the House to Senate for changes, amendments and a final agreement on the language. In the meantime, martial arts schools and other skills-based programs for children are in limbo. “First, we’re waiting for the Senate to schedule a second public hearing; 30 people that I gathered have already testified at the first hearing. We’ll be asking various famous athletics and martial artists to testify on our behalf. For instance, Mary Lou Retton, 1984 Olympics gymnastics champion, has already committed her support,” said Dudley. “I could have never taken on this fight without the support of my wife, Sandi, and my school’s staff. Dan Gonzalez, another San Antonio martial arts school owner, has been indispensable since the beginning, and Danny Pasemore, the president of the Texas Martial Arts Hall of Fame, has also helped to move this process forward. “Although the new rules in the legislation we are fighting won’t take effect until September 2010, we can’t relax for a moment. That’s why those of us fighting on the front lines of this battle are happy to know that NAP- MA, its members and the entire industry have the means to show their support through the special NAPMA Web site,” Dudley added. MAP Martial Arts Professional and NAP- MA agree with Master Dudley that the martial arts industry wants reasonable legislation to protect children from injury, child abductors and predators, and unscrupulous business practices.

Each of the industries that provide skills-training and other activities for children must also be protected from legislators and government regulators, who try to legislate those industries with little or no knowledge about how they operate and the many benefits they provide.

You are encouraged to visit NAP- MA.com/TexasLaw to lend your voice to this fight and also enlist the support of your friends and fellow school owners.

Legislative Update:

New Jersey Bill Still Poses Threat to Martial Arts Industry Martial Arts Professional reported on the Fitness Professionals Licensing Act (New Jersey Senate Bill 2164) in the December 2008/January 2009 issue. Senator Paul A. Sarlo introduced the bill during October 2008, requiring all “fitness professionals” (as defined by the bill) to be licensed. To qualify for said license, fitness professionals (which include martial arts instructors) would have to: • Complete 300 in-person classroom hours. • Serve a 50-hour unpaid internship under a licensed professional. • Be of good moral character. • Have a high school education or the equivalent. • Pass an examination. •  Possess an associate or bachelor’s degree in physical education, exercise science, exercise physiology or adult fitness. According to the New Jersey State Legislature Web site and various news reports, there has been one hearing on the bill, but it is currently with the Senate Commerce Committee, and is projected to be amended there, and reintroduced during the spring. That means there is still time for you to show your support for this fight, as well, which you can do at NAPMA.com/LegislativeAlert. Add your name to the pre-written letter and then send it directly to the New Jersey legislators sponsoring and considering this bill.

Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in May 2009.

Cite this article: Martial Arts Professional staff, “School Owners Beware! New Government Regulations Could Force You to Close Your School,” Martial Arts Professional, May 1, 2009, https://www.martialartsprofessional.com/school-owners-beware-new-government-regulations-could-force-you-to-close-your-school/
Martial arts school owners: make November and December your two best months of 2026 without holiday sales. Get the free book Q4 Extraordinary Results by Stephen Oliver.

Martial Arts Professional

The Martial Arts Professional staff byline. Used for reported news, magazine archive material and editorial notes that are the work of the publication rather than a single contributor. Martial Arts Professional is the trade journal of the National Association of Professional Martial Artists (NAPMA), published since 1996.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button