Mixed-Up Martial Arts: “I Have Seen the Enemy, and It Is Us!”

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, November 2009, in “Cover Feature” (pages 25–27). See the full issue.
There are three trends in the economy and the martial arts industry that have combined to KILL more than 3,500 schools during 2009! The industry is in crisis. This is the first of a series of Martial Arts Professional feature stories that will explain why, and what you can and should do to FIX our industry.
I recently returned from the Martial Arts SuperShow in Las Vegas. For the first time, I noticed the “tipping point” among the martial arts crowd and, unfortunately, it’s back to the 1960s. I’d say conservatively 60%–70% of the audience was there for an UFC-fighter autograph and to learn the next way to choke someone out. At the recent and infamous UFC® 100, Brock Lesnar flipped off the crowd and boasted that he was going home to drink Coors Light® and what he would do to his wife that night.
MMA should be great for the industry, right? I believe it’s a huge paradox that many, perhaps, even most martial artists love this stuff (I am a conspicuous exception), while the industry may be down as much as 25%–30% during the last 12–15 months. Are these two trends related?
Maybe a brief line describing the ratings for UFC and the Ultimate Fighter answers that question, “…managed to win a spot as the top show on cable in the 18-to-34year-old male demographic.”
Interesting. Top spot in 18–34-year-old male demographic?
My description of the 18–34-year-old male demographic as prospective students is flakey and financially unstable, with a high dropout rate. Now, don’t get me wrong. As a promoter or TV producer, I’d love that demographic; young males buy beer, deodorant, and magazines; frequent bars and restaurants; they buy Ipods, consume nutritional supplements; and, in fact, this demographic is supporting a wide variety of media, including magazines, such as Maxim, Stuff, Men’s Health and others. So, how has MMA hurt our industry? At its peak, the martial arts school industry thrived (and continues to thrive) predominantly on the kids market. The “stable” section of the adult market has always been older than 18-34. MMA is a spectator sport that certainly does a great job attracting its target audience of males, 18-34; but, frankly, that’s a horrible audience for school owners looking to develop quality students.
As a quick aside—you may not remember, but the first UFC fights were in Denver, Colorado. They happened to be on the night prior to my NASKA World Tour Tournament, The Mile High Karate Classic. At UFC’s request, I did a co-promotion with it and, among other things, distributed flyers at its event that read, “You’ve seen the brutality, now learn about the art.” Personally, I was proud of that headline. Unfortunately, it didn’t work. The problem: the wrong audience (the male 18–34 demographic). Karate-Do: My Way of Life by Gichin Funakoshi exemplifies the martial arts that I love, not Iceman: My Fighting Life by Chuck Liddell and Chad Millman. Now, don’t misunderstand me. I, and others, have been studying Mixed Martial Arts long before UFC. I studied Judo during the 1960s, as did Bill Wallace, Chuck Norris and many others. Jeff Smith fought in one of the “ I have seen the enemy, and it is us!”
By Stephen Oliver, MBA, NAPMA CEO
OPPOSITE PAGE: Images, such as these, have led to the popularity of “Mixed-Up Martial Arts” and misleading your prospects into thinking that half-naked women and major body tattoos bear some relationship to the values you teach at your school. Run, don’t walk in the opposite direction; in fact, be very explicit with prospects that your school does not associate itself with MMA and what it represents.
earlier MMA championships during the 1970s in Hawaii. The concept of MMA is not new. Go watch Enter the Dragon to see Bruce Lee leading the charge during the 1960s and 1970s.
Unfortunately, the positive image of martial arts, as a clean-cut activity for kids and families that was portrayed in The Karate Kid movies and since, is being progressively eliminated by this image of MMA as “martial arts.” Maybe I just miss Mr. Miyagi teaching a progressively aging Ralph Macchio and continuing to hate the Karate Kid villain, Kreese.
Kreese: We do not train to be merciful here. Mercy is for the weak. Here, in the streets, in competition. A man confronts you; he is the enemy. An enemy deserves no mercy. I guess I continue to prefer the dialogue and images that encourage parents to be enthusiastic about spending money (preferably PLENTY of it) for training for their kids—and themselves.
Daniel: Hey, you ever get into fights when you were a kid? Miyagi: Huh, plenty. Daniel: Yeah, but it wasn’t like the problem I have, right?
Miyagi: Why? Fighting, fighting. Same, same. Daniel: Yeah, but you knew karate.
Miyagi: Someone always knows more. Daniel: You mean there were times when you were scared to fight?
Miyagi: Always scare. Miyagi hate fighting. Daniel: Yeah, but you like karate.
Miyagi: So?
Daniel: So, karate’s fighting. You train to fight. Miyagi: That what you think?
Daniel: [pondering] No.
Miyagi: Then why train?
Daniel: [thinks] So I won’t have to fight. Miyagi: [laughs] Miyagi have hope for you. I blame us; we’ve been our own worst enemy. Why have so many martial artists been swayed by the popular trends, and destroyed what we do? Many schools really have become “Mixed-Up Martial Arts.”
My suggestion: RUN; do not walk in the opposite direction. If you want to attract students who are educated, can pay a reasonable tuition and will stay for several years rather than several months, then you MUST not be associated with the expanding MMA image. That doesn’t mean that you don’t integrate various styles. There are many outstanding instructors and clean-cut schools, teaching Mixed Martial Arts, as a traditional style, which incorporates Judo, BJJ, Grappling and other styles. That form of MMA can be an excellent addition to any upgrade program (Black Belt Club, Master Club or Leadership program) to keep students excited and enthusiastic about progressing through the many years of your program.
I’ve discussed the MMA challenge with Bill Wallace, Joe Lewis, Jeff Smith, Carlos Machado, Steve LaVallee, Tim Kovar, Keith Hafner and many others in the industry. All of them agree with my perspective to some extent. Some highly successful school owners have embraced the MMA trend, but, frankly, I think it’s a very bad idea. Be aware that you will soon be competing with UFC facilities, LA Boxing® , Xtreme Couture MMA® , fitness gyms and many others that are opening as national franchises or corporate locations.
Now, wait a minute. Let me put this aside and contemplate… A few weeks after my trip to Las Vegas, I traveled to Cover Feature: MIXED-UP MARTIAL ARTS Captiomn to come “ …you MUST not be associated with the expanding MMA image.”
Washington, D.C. I attended a NASKA World Tour tournament (The U.S. Capital Classics), met with 25 school owners representing approximately 5,000 students, and then met several times with my instructor Grand Master Jhoon Rhee. The crowd at the NASKA World Tour event was mostly clean-cut, polite kids and adults, which are a stark contrast to the typical “cage fight” audience. School owners were dressed in suits and focused on their missions to contribute to their communities by helping their students expand their health and character.
Meeting with Jhoon Rhee and attending other events during my quick trip further reinforced my opinion about several important aspects of martial arts instruction in 2009 and beyond.
One of my favorite Jhoon Rhee quotes is: “Martial arts without philosophy is just street fighting.” Now, he’s obviously a visionary and, at times, not in sync with the current martial arts community because he’s focused on how he sees the future unfolding.
We discussed his development of Musical Forms (Martial Ballet). He explained that during the 1960s he foresaw that martial arts “fighting” would be unnecessary in the future; but rather, to safeguard martial arts, the “art” must be preserved over the “martial.”
Grand Master Rhee then explained that his concept was 100% congruent with our American Founding Fathers and the true purpose of human evolution. When he saw my skepticism, he quickly showed me the following quote from John Adams, second U.S. President, which will be included in Grandmaster Rhee’s soon-to-be-published biography. “I must study politics and war, that my sons may have the liberty to study mathematics and philosophy, natural history and naval architecture, in order to give their children a right to study painting, poetry, music, architecture, tapestry, and porcelain.”
Now, that’s very interesting.
To me, it seems that during the 1970s and 1980s most martial arts instructors had come around to Grand Master Rhee’s way of thinking. We practiced the “DO” arts to facilitate personal development. The movie, The Karate Kid, shared principles and values that were clear about developing discipline and confidence and avoiding violence. To my great disappointment, it seems that many practitioners and instructors have lost sight of what Grand Master Rhee has kept clearly in focus. For the vast majority, martial arts practice today should be purely about personal development. Clearly, our armed forces and police need effective fighting technique, but, frankly, that’s more often about modern weapons, not unarmed combat (hopefully).
If you don’t want to take Jhoon Rhee’s word for it (or even John Adams), then what about the kickboxing and point-fighting legend, Joe Lewis? He is perhaps the ultimate “old-school” tough guy still training students throughout the world. What does he have to say? It’s vital to recognize that martial arts training is not always about developing high quality physical skills. It’s about fitness and self-defense. Those mostly arise, however, from the mental and emotional development that is the result of rigorous martial arts practice. To add another point that Joe Lewis makes, the 1st-, 2nd- or 3rd-Degree Black Belt must be a starting point for personal development, just as a high school diploma should be a start to one’s learning throughout life. For a beginning student, achieving Black Belt is an appropriate early “benchmark” to begin quality personal development for life. It’s not an end in itself. Quality schools will (and do) constantly expand and enhance the definition of a Black Belt (and 2nd-, 3rd- and 4th- Degree Black Belts) and what students must attain. Marketing for martial arts schools should be about attracting quality students—never diluting the achievement and recognition of students and lowering standards of excellence. Teaching a curriculum that encompasses a range of techniques, and “uses what works,” is a hallmark of quality schools—foul-mouthed fighting, without philosophy, is not. MAP Let’s Restore the Dignity of a Black Belt Joe Lewis, NAPMA Technical Consultant “In one aspect of what is called ‘martial arts’, the MMA stuff, many Black Belts come across as heavily-tattooed, cartoonlooking hoodlums, who respect violence and feel free to curse and degrade others on national TV. “The media completely ignored us during the early sixties, but now seemingly only grant visibility to those who believe that it’s in vogue to condone violence and/or that it is okay to send kids the message that adults accept the use of violence as a means to resolve problems. This is not the message to which parents want their children exposed or taught to value. Just as ‘Pro Wrestling’ is not real wrestling; in a way, perhaps, MMA is not real martial arts. “Violence by definition is a ‘loss of self-co ntrol’. Martial arts teaches self-control; therefore, martial arts is not violent—people are. Guns (for the gun control freaks) do not kill others—bullets do. “We must wake up—Black Belts are leaving the martial arts in droves. We must re-validate and grant dignity to the meaning of the old definition of a Black Belt. Either it does not mean anything any longer (in this fanatical martial arts marketing atmosphere) or it has become the finish line, which determines at what point during one’s journey he call it quits. SAD!”
Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in November 2009.



