Your Waiver Is a Blanket, Not a Wall. A Massachusetts Court Just Pulled It Off.

By Stephen Oliver, MBA, 10th Degree Black Belt
A five-year-old girl climbed onto a bar at the beam station, tried to sit on it, fell, and broke her arm. A coach was in the room. The date was October 10, 2021.
Her father had signed a waiver. He had signed it twice, actually — once at enrollment in October 2020 and again, word for word identical, at re-enrollment in August 2021. It said what yours says. It waived “any and all claims of liability” and held the company and its franchisees harmless “in the event that such injury . . . may occur to me or my child.”
That piece of paper did exactly one thing. It bought the business a summary judgment in Worcester Superior Court and about four years of litigation, after which the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts took the case on its own initiative, read the waiver, and threw it in the trash.
Now here is the sentence I actually want you to sit with. The statute the court used to void that waiver — a law on the books since 1985 — contains its own list of the businesses it governs, and that list says, in the Legislature’s words, “martial arts and self-defense schools, or any other similar course of physical training.”
Not an analogy. Not a court stretching a definition to reach you. You are named in the statute. The gymnastics center had to argue its way in. You are already there.
What the Court Actually Did
The case is Cross v. BeFree Enterprises, LLC, SJC-13933, argued September 9, 2026 and decided November 10, 2026. Justice Wolohojian wrote for the full court — Chief Justice Budd and Justices Gaziano, Kafker, Wendlandt, Georges and Dewar sitting. The defendant does business as The Little Gym of West Boylston.
The holding is one line: “the liability waiver is unenforceable and does not bar Ava’s negligence claim.” The summary judgment was vacated and the case was remanded for further proceedings. Whether that gym was negligent has not been decided and may never be. That is not the point. The point is that the defense everyone in this industry relies on evaporated at the appellate level and the case is now back in front of a jury.
The mechanism is three sections of Massachusetts General Laws, chapter 93. Section 80 bars waivers in health club contracts. Section 85 says a contract that doesn’t comply “shall be void and unenforceable as contrary to public policy.” And section 78 defines what a “health club” is — any facility or business offering “facilities for or instruction, training or assistance in the preservation, maintenance” of physical fitness, conditioning or well-being, followed by a list of examples that the court went out of its way to describe as non-exclusive: health spas, sports, tennis, health studios, gymnasiums, weight control centers, and martial arts and self-defense schools. The companion definition of a “contract for health club services” is even more explicit. It names “the teaching of martial arts including judo, karate and self-defense.”
The gym’s lawyers made the argument you would make. They said this isn’t a gym, it’s an early-childhood enrichment program — child development, social-emotional learning, cognitive development, parent-and-child classes starting at four months old. The court’s answer was four words long in substance: “that is not the question.” What it actually wrote was, “Although Little Gym may indeed have features that traditional exercise gyms do not, that is not the question.” The question was whether the business offers instruction in developing physical fitness. It does. Coaches, classes, equipment, motor and gymnastic skills. Done.
And then, in reasoning that reads like it was written for this magazine, the court said: “Like Little Gym, martial arts and self-defense schools offer classes with instructors, and often to children.”
One more thing about the mechanics, because owners get this wrong constantly. The waiver was a separate document from the enrollment paperwork. The gym argued that mattered. It didn’t. The court read the waiver, the enrollment forms and the payment together as a single transaction forming one contract for health club services. Your “that’s not part of the agreement, it’s a separate release” argument is already dead in Massachusetts and I would not bet a school on it anywhere else.
Before You Relax Because You’re Not in Massachusetts
Let me begin by saying the obvious: I am not a lawyer, this is not legal advice, and the answer to “does this reach my school” depends entirely on the statutes of your own state or country. Go buy an hour of a local lawyer’s time. An hour. That is the cheapest risk management available to you and almost none of you have bought it.
But don’t get my statement above wrong, either. The court dropped a footnote noting that Hawaii, Maryland and New York have statutes of their own restricting these waivers, and citing cases from Michigan, Pennsylvania and Washington. It cited a Pennsylvania trampoline-park decision, Santiago v. Philly Trampoline Park, for the proposition that courts disfavor waivers signed on behalf of children. The court didn’t rely on any of that — it didn’t have to, it had a statute — but it noticed it. And appellate judges in other states read each other’s opinions.
So the landscape, roughly, has three zones. There are states with a statute that voids these clauses outright. There are states where courts have held that a parent generally cannot sign away a minor child’s claims, which gets to the same place by a different road. And there is everywhere else, where your waiver probably works — against an adult, for ordinary negligence, if it’s conspicuous, if it’s specific, if it was signed by the person whose claim it’s waiving, and if whatever happened wasn’t gross negligence or a violation of a safety statute.
Count the conditions in that last sentence. Six. Now go count how many of your students are under eighteen. In most schools in this industry the children’s programs are the majority of the roll, and in plenty of them they are the overwhelming majority — you know your own number, so go look at it. Then understand what it means: the waiver you have been relying on is at its strongest exactly where you need it least, and at its weakest across most of your tuition.
The Quick List: Why Owners Get This Wrong
I have been in the trenches in this business for over fifty years, and I can tell you definitively that the waiver conversation in martial arts is one of the great exercises in self-soothing. Here is the diagnosis, enumerated, because that is how I think about it.
- The waiver is treated as a substitute for insurance. It is not. It never was. One of them pays a claim; the other one is an argument. If your general liability limits haven’t been reviewed since you signed the lease, you do not have a waiver problem, you have an insurance problem wearing a waiver as a disguise.
- The form came from somewhere nobody remembers. It came from the franchisor, or from a seminar binder in 2009, or from another school’s website at two in the morning. It has never been read by a lawyer licensed where you teach. A document nobody professionally reviewed is not a legal instrument. It is a comfort blanket with your logo on it.
- Nobody distinguishes between a waiver and an assumption-of-risk acknowledgment. They are different animals and in a jurisdiction where the first is void the second may still do real work. “I understand that sparring involves contact and the risk of bruising, sprains and broken bones” is an admission a plaintiff has to live with. “I waive all claims” may be a nullity. Most school forms smear the two together.
- The claim that kills you isn’t the injury. It’s the supervision. Read the Massachusetts facts again. A coach was present. The allegation was failure to supervise. Mats and medical forms do not answer a supervision allegation. A written standard, a trained staff and a record do.
- There is no record. No attendance-to-incident trail, no equipment log, no dated photo of the bag mount, no signed acknowledgment that the instructor read the floor procedure. In litigation, the school with no paper is presumed to have had no system. In my experience that presumption is usually correct.
- The owner has never priced the downside. Everybody in this business can tell me their monthly gross. Almost nobody can tell me their policy limits, their deductible, whether their coverage includes abuse and molestation, whether their instructors are covered teaching off-site at a school demo, or whether their landlord’s lease pushes an indemnity obligation onto them. That is not risk management. That is hoping.
What Actually Protects a School
Years ago I started talking about the Parthenon — the idea that your lead generation should never be one pillar, because the day the one pillar cracks, the roof is on your head. Every owner who has ever lived on a single marketing channel has learned that lesson expensively.
Risk is the same architecture and almost nobody builds it that way. Your waiver is one pillar, and in Massachusetts, as of November 10, it is rubble. Here are the pillars that hold the roof up when it goes.
Insurance you have actually read. Limits, deductible, defense costs inside or outside the limits, abuse and molestation coverage, off-premises coverage for demos and camps, additional-insured status for your landlord, and whether your independent instructors are covered at all. If you cannot answer those from memory, you are not insured, you are merely paying premiums. Call your broker this week and make them walk you through it line by line.
A written floor standard, one page. Student-to-instructor ratio by age group. Who is on the mat for the little kids’ class and where they stand. What a staff member does when a child is crying, bleeding, or climbing on something not meant to be climbed on. No exceptions — and I mean that in the specific sense I always mean it, which is that a standard with exceptions is not a standard, it is a preference.
An equipment and facility log. Dated. Initialed. Bags, mounts, mats, mirrors, the loose tile by the door, the thing in the corner the kids climb. Ten minutes a week. This is the single cheapest piece of litigation defense in existence and I have seen maybe one school in twenty keep one.
An incident report that gets filled out for the small ones. Not just the ambulance calls. The jammed finger, the nosebleed, the kid who sat out. Date, time, who was teaching, what happened, what was done, who the parent spoke to. A school that documents fifty small incidents a year and handles them well looks completely different in a deposition than a school whose file is empty until the day somebody breaks an arm.
Background checks and the camera question. Every adult on the floor, every time, renewed. And then answer the camera question in writing, because almost nobody has: who in your school can view, download or remove video footage, is it logged, and who reviews the log? Cameras are a safeguarding asset when access to the footage is controlled and a liability the moment it is not. On the kids’ market I have never once regretted being too conservative, and I have watched owners lose everything by being only slightly casual.
And then the forms, properly drafted. Last on the list, not first. An assumption-of-risk acknowledgment that is specific to what you actually teach. A medical and emergency-contact form that is current. A photo release. An enrollment agreement that survives your state’s consumer-contract and auto-renewal rules — which, as we have reported here repeatedly through this year, are multiplying. Drafted by somebody licensed where you teach, reviewed every two years.
The Part Nobody Wants to Hear
Every few years this industry decides something external is going to kill it. I have lived through all of them. The Karate Kid was going to flood us and then abandon us. Kung Fu, Enter the Dragon, the Ninja Turtles, Tae Bo, the MMA boom — each one arrived with somebody telling me the business was over. None of them killed a single school. What killed schools was owners who chased the trend badly, spent money they didn’t have on a fad, and stopped answering the phone at ten in the morning.
A court decision is a different animal, and I want to be precise about why. A trend changes your marketing. A liability ruling changes your downside. Those are not the same kind of risk. A bad quarter costs you a quarter. One uninsured supervision claim against a school with no documentation costs you the school, the house behind it, and the thirty years of goodwill you built in a town where everybody knows your name.
And notice who the plaintiff is in these cases. It is not a stranger. It is a family that was on your roll, that liked you, whose kid wore your patch. Nobody in Cross set out to destroy a children’s gym. A child got hurt, a family had medical bills and a question that wasn’t answered well, and a legal system did what legal systems do. The schools that get sued are not the schools with bad people in them. They are the schools with no system — where the answer to “who was watching?” is a shrug, and the answer to “what’s your procedure?” is “we’ve always just handled it.”
Here is reality: this is a REALLY simple business that owners make complicated, and the simple version of this week’s lesson is that you are selling instruction to children in a physical environment, and the law in a growing number of places has decided that a business like yours cannot contract its way out of the duty that comes with that. You can be angry about it or you can be ready for it. The statute in Massachusetts has said your business is covered since 1985. For forty-one years every school owner in that state could have known. How many did?
Do This Before Friday
Pull your enrollment packet out of the drawer right now — the actual one, not the one you think you use — and put it on your desk next to your insurance declarations page. Then make two calls. The first is to a lawyer in your own state, and the question is: is a martial arts school a regulated category under any consumer or health-club statute here, and does that statute limit what I can put in this agreement? The second is to your broker, and the question is: read me my limits, my deductible, my abuse and molestation coverage, and tell me whether my part-time instructors are covered.
Then write your one-page floor standard. Today. Not a manual, not a project for January — one page, ratios and responsibilities, and have every instructor sign it before Saturday’s little kids’ class.
P.S. — If your reaction to all of this was “my waiver has held up fine for twenty years,” understand that the gym in Massachusetts could have said the same thing on November 9. Nobody finds out their waiver is void on a quiet Tuesday. They find out in year four of a lawsuit, after a child is already hurt.
Sources: Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, Cross v. BeFree Enterprises, LLC, SJC-13933, decided November 10, 2026 (slip opinion, subject to formal revision); Business Insurance, November 12, 2026. Nothing in this column is legal advice. The waiver question turns on the statutes and case law of your own jurisdiction, and it is worth an hour of a local lawyer’s time.


