Seven Laws of Success Without Selling Out, Part X: How to Choose a Billing Company

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, March 1997, in “Seven Laws of Success” (pages 21–22). See the full issue.
WITHOUT SELLING OUT PART X the law of multiplied efforts BY JOHN GRADEN HOW TO CHOOSE A BILLING COMPANY ne area of a school’s operation that the Law of Multiplied Efforts definitely applies to is in the collection of student tuition. With very rare exceptions, schools should use a thirdparty billing company to process their students’ accounts.
We are martial artists, not accountants. We’re definitely not bill collectors. Typically, when a student walks up to you and says something to the effect that his income has been negatively affected and, consequently, he is going to negatively affect your income, most of usare very understanding.
My instructor let me clean the school for my lessons. (Since I quit football the year before, my parents wouldn’t pay the $25 per month for karate lessons). I was the original “wax-on, wax-off” kid. So when a parent or student tells me they are having a hard time paying tuition that month, Tm kind of a softy.
This is unfortunate because, most of the time the money was simply mismanaged or spent on other disposable purchases. That’s not my fault, but I’m being made to pay for it. Seldom is it really a family crisis that dictates tight budget. If itis, then I will certainly make arrangements to help them out if Ican.
Good Guy/Bad Guy
When a student comes up and asks for a break on his tuition, it puts you ina very uncomfortable position. If you do not havea third-party billing company, you’re forced to change roles in the eyes of the student. You go from caring, compassionate instructor to cold, calculating bill collector. This can be cancerous to the instructor/student relationship.
However, if you have a third-party billing company, you can raise your hands, smile and say, “Mrs. Jones, L understand completely. I just had to pay for a brake job | myself. However, | don’thave anything to do with your tui ion arrange- I’m only interested in the martial arts aspect of the school We have a company in Texas that handles all of our student’s accounts Here’s the phone number. Ask for Rick Bell, he’s a good guy and he’ll see what he can do to help you. By the way, how’s Johnny coming with his new kick…?” One of the most powerful advanta of a third-party billing company is that it allows you to be the good guy and the billing company to be the bad guy Of course, if a student really needs some help, you should be able to contact the billing company and have them make whatever adjustments you like. Your billing company should be very | polite, but firm with these students. They meni frustration. absolutely should not tell the student sion about what to do ol owner. that the final de: rests with you, the Instead, if special arrangements are warranted, they should tell the student they will present it to their “supervisor” consideration and then r get back to them Then the company should contact inal decisions about adjustin This allows you to objectively deal with the situation without the pressure of being cornered by a mom you to make any the account. in between classes. continued,
22 MARTIAL ARTS PROFESSIONAL MARCH ‘97
Methods of Payment EFT The single, most effective method of collecting tuition is with the Electronic Funds ‘Transfer (EFT). EFTs automatically debit the student’s account on the same day each month for either a specified number of months or for as long as the student remains active. This eliminates the decisionmaking process from the student’s mind. ‘They cannot push aside the tuition pay ment to make the dance lesson payment. The payments are made automatically. While some banks can set up an EFT account for collecting your tuition, you lose the advantage of good guy/bad guy. You are also faced with doing all of the accounting and follow-up on payments that are returned with Non Sufficient Funds (NSF). The service fee for collecting EFTs is low enough to delegate it to a billing company that specializes in EFTs. Let them do all the accounting and follow-up collections. Remember, with the Law of Multiplied Ef forts, your goal is to delegate the tasks that are not your specialty.
Coupon Books ‘The most common method of third-party billing in our industry is the coupon-book system. Similar in process to purchasing a car, the student is mailed a coupon book containing the payment information that is mailed in with each monthly payment. ‘Typically, coupon books are used with students on contract. Though contracts can and arguably should, be collected with EFT, many schools prefer the more traditional coupon-book process.
Coupon books require the student to go through the process of writing a check, completing the coupon, inserting itinto an envelope, addressing the envelope and affixing postage in order to pay tuition. On the other hand, EFTs require only that the money be in the bank. The computers will handle the rest.
Selling Your Contracts
When you sell your contract to a billing company for a percentage ofthe face value to be paid to you in advance for a lump sum, you are creating a liability for your school. Until the lessons are completed, the money the company has advanced to you isnot yours. Ifthe student should drop out or get injured and demand a refund, you may be liable for the unused amount. Often the company will “allow” you to use the next contract you sell to offset the one that went bad. Rather than pay you, they keep 100% of the contract to make up for the student that quit. Now, you’ve lost the first contract and you won’t be collecting anything on the second. Thisis the start of avery dangerous cycle, If the new contract is not collected in fall, the cycle will ust continue until you’re literally scrambling for new students. Not to make your school grow, but to satisfy the monster you’ve created. ‘To be fair, there are some schools who have had success with this type of arrangement. These tend to be very large schools, with enough capital in the bank to offset the losses. If a contract goes bad, they refund the money to the billing company. However, for most schools, the allure ofthe “quick payoff” is quickly diminished by the huge liabilities it creates. Also, once the billing company pays you in advance for the contract, they own it. They are free to take whatever measures allowed by law to collect the tuition, regardless of the effect on the student’s credit or the student’s relationship with the school. This can lead to a very bad reputation in town.
Service Fees
Minimums ‘Most billing companies require a minimum-activity level in order to maintain your account, Schools falling under the designated level in activity are charged a monthly “minimum” service fee. This is very common and, frankly, understandable. Billing is a very expensive, laborintensive business with very narrow margins. Say you have only ten accounts with a company, totalling $600 in EFT collections per month, and the billing company is charging 4% to collect them. They will gross, before expenses, a whopping $24 off those accounts. That’s a lot of processing and follow-up for S24. ‘Hence, the minimum.
Most minimums range from $100-$250. Only the smallest of schools, in most cases, should have any problems making most companies’ required minimums. Other companies require you to sign an exclusive contract with penalties for using any other company. This is a decision you’ll have to make. Some schools like having all accounts with one company. Others like to take advantage of the specialties of different companies. For instance, coupon books with one company and EFTs with another. ‘Others simply don’t like to have all of their eggs in one basket.
Service Fees
Most billing companies charge 10% for collecting coupon books. EFT collections range from 4%-79%. Others charge “per transaction.” Some as low as 25¢. These companies tend to require higher volumes and stricter minimums, so be sure to investigate before sending off all of your school’s receivable accounts to anyone. Which brings us to our next subject, trust.
The horror stories abound. Schools forced into closing because their billing company disappeared with all of their tuition revenues. Students who drop out because the billing company harasses them day and night. Instructors forced into bankruptcy after being caught in the vicious cycle of replacing the contracts they sold to a contract-buying company. In an industry with along history of unprofessionalism, it’s not easy to send all of your tuition collections to a stranger across the count there are companies who have long histories of servicing the martial arts industry.
A little esearch and networking with your professional association should help you find the stable institutions with good track records.
It’s a good idea to perform your due diligence when selecting a billing company. It could be one of the best, or one of the worst decisions you’ll make for your school. Still, he decision is not whether or not you should use a third party to collect your tuition. The question is: Whom do you use? Your job is to create and keep students, Not create and collect accounts.
Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in March 1997.



