Archive Articles

How Minor Details Can Prevent Major Lawsuits

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, February 1998 (pages 12–15). See the full issue.

COVER STORY 4 during class, we know that there is a risk that we’ll single accident or lawsui y most martial arts schools, or end programs at churches and recreation centers. While most schools try to maintain a safe environment while ing, but it is inevitable that pec martial arts. Most of us maintain insurance to tec a us from cataclysmic litigation,and we have “Hold Harm less” agreements or waivers to protect us from claims. Still, every time a student is injured during class, we e know that there is a risk that we’ll be out of business. Ourinsurance has policy limits, and claims on our policies can result in cancellation Many of us know that “Hold Harmless” documents may not stand up in a court of law. Courts have consis- | tently maintained that you cannot waive your right to sue if someone else is negligent. After signed waiver or not, an injured student or the parent of a minor student may file a claim with your insurance, send you medical bills for the injury o & | Having a good insurance policy is importan one expensive case could close down a school. W you have insurance or not, though suits altogether is by fa Taking the issue of accidents step-by-step, the first gensquire | eral issue to consider is avoiding accidents. No matter MARTIAL ARTS PROFESSIONAL RUARY “98

COVER STORY nce of training the present situation with documentation or insurance, if no accidents occur, then there will be The first thing to do is evaluate the safety of your training area. Any potential dangers need to be addressed. If there is a tear in the mat that could catch someone’s foot, then it should be taped down or the mat replaced. Look at your training hall from the standpoint of a nit-picking safety inspector. Do not dismiss things as “good enough,”since in a court of law “good enough” often isn’t. Carefully explore both the actual training area and the rest of your premises. 0 claim.

Some cor non da Torn Mats + Uneven Floor + Protruding Objects (nails, splinters, etc. + Equipment Improperly Stored (stacke so it may fall over; weapons loosely mounted on a wall;equipment in training areas; etc. + Sticky or Slick Areas on Hard Floor + Chemicals (usually in restrooms, etc.) + Poorly Lit Areas (especially training areas Another area tocarefully evaluate is the safety of your training equipment. If weapons have splinters, then they should be sanded down or replaced. If the grips on sai are coming loose, then they need to be secured. Ifa cord on nunchukus is frayed or there isa crack in the weapon, they must be replaced. Sharp weapons should be stored well out of the way of curious visi tors or students.

The standard, when evaluating equipment, is the same. Look over every piece of equipment as though you were looking for an excuse to sue your own school. Some common dangers are: plintering or Cracked Weapons juipmient can hi ‘avoid student + Old Kicking Shields + Stressed Chains on Heavy Bags + Fraying Cord on Speed Bags + Loose Grips on Weapons + Worn Mats + Sharp Weapons + Nunchukus, Three-Section Staves, Eight-Section Whips and other weapons with which the inexperienced can easily injure themselves If you find any potential dangers, address the problem as soon as time and money allow. Do not delay. If an accident happens today because of a problem you meant to fix tomorrow, you will feel like a fool. If you’ve never had an acci then now is the time to take care of the problems. You do not want to wait until a student is injured before you try to make a safe training hall The third thing to look for in avoidin tual training. Martial arts, by its nature, has an element of dangerto it. Students will get minor injuries through the course of their training. The injuries might be as slight as a tended joint orastrained muscle, or as serious as or fractured bone.

Some commor 1 dangers are * Weapons practice in or near traffic areas (a traffic area is not just a walkway, but anywhere that other students move through, even if they are traininga + Students wandering through otf practice. One very high-profile school owner nearly had to declare bankruptcy well r student’ 4 MARTIAL A RTS PROFESSIONAL

Cardio-KarateTM programs, which are mostly made up of women clients, introduces a whole new dimension of possible when a teenage student turned to run across the training floor and ran face-first into a full-power spinning hook kick thrown by an instructor. The git!’ face had to be rebuilt. Fortunately, the owner’s insurance was able to cover the $1-million claim. + Students holding kicking shields who hit too hard for them + Students training with sharp weapons + Sparring with excessive contact (often as a result of students sparring at a speed too fast for their level of control + Rolling or falling on a hard floor while learning how to fall. (Recommendation: use a mat to learn, then the hard floor once some proficiency is developed. * Wrist Locks, throws or self-defense skills practiced too hard. (Recommendation: Go too light until you learn an individual training partner’s pain and injury thresholds. heavy bags for others Avoiding Lawsuits If you’ve made a reasonable effort to avoid accidents in your school, you may never face the problem of a claim or lawsuit, Still, even those of us who might be inclined to take the gamble of teaching without insurance (definitely NOT recommended) ‘would not think ofteaching without a waiver signed. As mentioned earlier, waivers generally do not hold up in court. To address this problem, I use an “Assumption of the Risk. There is some caselaw to support assumption of the risk as a defense to lawsuits. The document itself has not been held up to scrutiny by the court, but when you know one thing will not work (the waiver) then you try something else. The rule of law goes something like this: If you knew the danger, and you did it anyway, and you got hurt because of the danger you knew about, then you cannot sue. Why this concept isn’t applied more successfully to martial arts training without use of a form I do not know. Physicians have patients sign documents after the doctor informs them ofthe danger of a surgery. Its called “informed consent,” an assumption of the risk, and it seems to stand up in court. Essentially, an Assumption of the Risk should advise a student of the danger of training in martial arts, and include clauses that indicate that the student assumes the risk of injury and assumes responsibility for his own safety. My students have the right to tell me if they do not feel something is safe,and we discuss it. This exchange often results in a change in the drill, or, at times, elimination of a drill. So longas you allow your students to have the authority to change or eliminate routines because ofsafety concerns, then the clause has meaning. If you do not allow for this, then the clause might easily be defeated in court. ‘As an addition, I have an arbitration clause in my docu ments, Should an accident occur and the student files suit, then there isa contractual provision for binding arbitration. This makes it quicker and cheaper to litigate if I do not feel that the cause of action is justified. The rules of arbitration are generally more relaxed than the strict evidence and pro- + cedure rules of court, and it greatly reduces the cost of defending a case For minors, I have both the parent and the child sign a special Assumption of the Risk for Minors document. It includes all the he normal Assumption of the Risk, but addsspecific responsibilities that the parent assumes. The most important of these is that the parent indemnifies the school and its instructors for any damages sought by or on behalf of the student.

A common document problem is that minors cannot be bound by a document they sign. Parents cannot sign away the rights of their children, no matter how young the child. In order to get around this problem, we have the parent and child both assume the risk of harm to the child, and then have the parents indemnify us. While they cannot sign away their child’s right to sue, they can, by virtue of this clause, give us the right to request that they pay for any money we have to pay as a result of lti lauses tion.

Sexual Harassment, Assault, and Molestation

An additional liability issue is the much talked-about and, these days, somewhat popular claims of sexual harassment, and its companion, sexual assault. We must also consider child molestation. Why these are such important issues for us is that men, women and children often train together, and their bodies often touch. If there are groin attacks in a system, then intimate areas of the body are also touched. While most men MARTIAL ARTS PROFESSIONAL FEBRUARY

Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in February 1998.

Cite this article: Scot Conway, “How Minor Details Can Prevent Major Lawsuits,” Martial Arts Professional, February 1, 1998, https://www.martialartsprofessional.com/how-minor-details-can-prevent-major-lawsuits/
Martial arts school owners: make November and December your two best months of 2026 without holiday sales. Get the free book Q4 Extraordinary Results by Stephen Oliver.

Scot Conway

Scot Conway wrote for the print edition of Martial Arts Professional. Columns and articles are republished from the magazine archive with their original issue dates.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button