Good Question! How to Overcome a Student’s Personal Problems

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, July 1998, in “Good Question!” (pages 30–31). See the full issue.
ACMA Consultation
We have an adult student with some personal problems. She was abused as a child and has a real problem with male adult superiors. She’s on medication (anti-depressants) and just quit smoking. She came in today crying hysterically. We are at a loss. Our chief instructor is male, our assistant instructor is, too. She’s okay when she’s in my class (I’m a woman). What can we do, if anything? Or is this just too much for us to take on? ‘Name Withheld by Request Response:
One of the greatest challenges that instructors face is dealing with the communication and relationship issues which come from working with a variety of students in a demanding training environment. Occasionally, the personal characteristics ofthe student and instructor may mixin such a manner as to present barriers in the communication and training process. The goal for the instructor is to recognize and overcome these barriers, and give the best quality of instruction possible to that individual. ‘One potential barrier to effective communication can come from the way in which instructors see” their students. For example, if a male instructor knows that a student has a history of abuse and depression, and that she tends to react in a highly emotional manner, his communication with her can be biased by that perception. The instructor may have a concern that saying much, if anything, to this student may upset her. The result may be that he rarely speaks to this person at all. fortunately, focusing on this student’s “problems” can, in fact, subtly perpetuate and escalate the difficulties which already exist. In the above example, the instructor’s actions are out of concern for this student’s emotional well-being. The student, however, may feel offended, or neglected ifthe instructor rarely speaks to her. The result is to further impair the communication between them.
An alternative to the “problem focus” is to consciously and consistently focus on the student’s strengths. It appears that this individual values the benefits which she receives by training in the martial arts at your school. That is, she continues to attend classes even though this is, at times, an emotionally difficult experience for her. This requires a certain amount ofpersonal strength and determination on her part.
Asan instructor, it is helpful to recognize and emphasize this strength. One manner of recognition is to appropriately compliment her determination. A simple statement such as, L admire the effort you put into coming in regularly and training,” can do a lot to boost her self-confidence, and your communication. However it is done, the essential element is to find and focus on the personal characteristics of this student which can contribute to success in her training. Another barrier to communication can come from the way in which a person’s feelings influence his or her behavior in certain situations. If a student becomes upset and responds to instruction in an | inappropriately defensive or angry manner, the instructor may feel frustrated (a normal reaction), Although the student may not be considering the impact of his or her own behavior, the instructor does not have this luxury.
Given that this student “has a real problem with male adult superiors,” some feelings of frustration probably accompany working with her on occasion, As professionals, instructors must consistently respond to all students with the objective of assisting them in being successful in their training. Thus, the instructor must continue communicating and teaching in an effective manner, despite whatever feelings may exist.
In order to accomplish this end, it is helpful to remain supportive and task-focused. If the objective is to teach the student how to perform a kick correctly, the emphasis within the communication must be on the elements of the kick. If the student becomes defensive by saying something like, “You’re pushing me too hard to. do this kick the way you want, you’re never satisfied,” acknowledge that, “It is difficult to perform the kick”
Reinforce her efforts by pointing out the elements of her kick which are correct and can be built upon. Assure her that she can learn at her own pace. This type of response shows appropriate recognition of her frustration and support, yet focuses on her progress in performing the kick, and encourages her to continue in her attempts.
By emphasizing the student’s strengths and remaining task-focused, you encourage the student to do the same. Over time, this should help diminish the number of problems which are present in the communication, and make training a more rewarding experience for the student and instructors alike.
Cardio – Karate ards & Belt.Ceremonies drén’s Classes Traditional Ambience Team Demonstrations Creative Musical Forms Instructional Videos The Only Martial Arts Music Company – 4- BK -HOWE { COMBAT HAPKIDO!
Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in July 1998.



