Columnists

As I See It: Traditional Methods vs. Traditional Techniques

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, March 1998, in “As I See It” (page 4). See the full issue.

Traditional Techniques ne of the most confusing aspects of learning new methods of teaching marital arts is the emotional attachment many instructors have tothe way they were taught. Ifyou were ra in the arts under a certain atmosphere and attitude by your instructor, and you are still in the arts, odds are that your instructor’s methods ap- ‘pealed to you in some way. fact that you didn’t drop out under » tor indicates a certain affection for his methods of teaching, good or bad.

The challenge is when we then turn around nother words, the very. ur instruc and teach our students in the same manner in which we were taught. This is not such a problem in some cases where the instructor was professional, patient, and positive. However, this was not always the case for many of us. Partic began your training anytime before the mid-198 when the level of instruction began to improve, albeit slowly. larly, if you r EEIT om the should remember that many of the first-generation instructors in America learned on military bases— or in off-base schools—in the Far East.

The classes in which they learned were, in most cases, long and brutal. The instructors didn’t always enjoy teaching the “barbarian Americans, but enjoyed having such big, tough men to work over, The classes were very strict—designed for highlydisciplined adult military American men by highly-disciplined adult, often military, Asian men, They were not designed for six-year-old children or a mom who hasn’t exercised in 20 years because she’s been raising a family This is where the teaching pattern began that has, in many ways, plagues this industry to this day. These firstgeneration black belts, many of whom earned their black belt in the 18 oF so months they were stationed in a particular area, came back to the states and began teaching classes. We are indebted to their passion for thearts, for bringing them back to the states. Nevertheless, the problem is that they tended to teach the classes in the same manner they were taught, since they knew no better way.

Much like an abused child tends to grow up to be an abuser, our industry has been faced with a multi-generational pattern of inappropriate, and ofien, unsafe teaching practices, simply because that’s the only way the instructor knew how to teach, Indeed, this became the “traditional way” of teaching for this instructor. Here, itis important to makea dis. tinction. We’re describing “traditional teaching methods’ as opposed to“traditional techniques or systems.” There is a huge difference and it’s one that has proved to be confusing to many well-intentioned instructors. Our goal with the American Council on Martial Arts (ACMA), is to provide the most modern, scientificallyproven “teaching methods” that publisher should allow you to be even more effective in teaching the “traditional techniques” of your system. For instance, an instructor may teach a tra~ ditional side kick in an inappropriate, unprofessional and unsafe manner. This is the way he has always taught the side kick, and it’s the way he was taught sidekick. It’s the school’s traditional way of presenting the side kick. Though the mechanics do adhere to the specific martial arts style he is teaching, the presentation method may be entirely inappropriate for his class’ age or skill level. The ACMA-certified instructor, on the other hand, would teach the same side kick, with the same style-requisite mechanics, but more effectively —by teaching a traditional side kick by means ofamuch more age/skillspecific presentation and methodology.

Both instructors teach the exact same traditional technique with the same stylistic mechanics, but the presentation and teaching methodology may vary drastically. The result is, the students should be less frustrated, and less prone to injury or humiliation, Best ofall, they should be more apt to stay involved with the school for a longer period of time and with higher skill retention, than the instructor who teaches “the old school way.” In many ways, this is the best of both worlds. Instructors are able to teach their preferred traditional style, but with new teaching methods proven scientifically toenhance retention and motivation. This allows an instructor to maintain his traditional system, but offers the potential to increase student retention and the popularity of the school by using the most effective teaching methods known. bx GRADEN Publisher

Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in March 1998.

Cite this article: John Graden, “As I See It: Traditional Methods vs. Traditional Techniques,” Martial Arts Professional, March 1, 1998, https://www.martialartsprofessional.com/as-i-see-it-traditional-methods-vs-traditional-techniques/
Martial arts school owners: make November and December your two best months of 2026 without holiday sales. Get the free book Q4 Extraordinary Results by Stephen Oliver.

John Graden

John Graden wrote for the print edition of Martial Arts Professional. Columns and articles are republished from the magazine archive with their original issue dates.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button