Columnists

As I See It: The Eagle Scout Syndrome

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, August 1997, in “As I See It” (page 4). See the full issue.

HS 1 SEE IT letter The Eagle Scout Syndrome ‘goodfriend of mine, a 52-year-old baby boomer, was lamenting the lack of appeal that today’s martial arts school has for a baby boomer like himself and his wife. He was frustrated that many schools tend to treat adults like children. More focus is spent (on reciting “good citizenship” merits than learning selfdefense. At least it seemed that way to him. “I’m an adult” he explained, “I pay my taxes and don’t break the law. Don’t tell me how to live.” Once overcame my instinct to defend the schools, his point struck a chord. With the media-spawned boom in the children’s market ofthe past decade, many of us have inadvertently forgotten the adult. When I began training in 1974, the majority of the students were adults, specficalh were some kids, but they were tolerated more than targeted. They seemed like a natural by-product of the allure of the Bruce Lee chopsocky, kung-fu boom. The image of the martial arts black belt was that of a serious, somewhat roughneck male, How did we get {from that to “Ninja Turtle Parties?” Clear rate Kid” films had something to do with it. adult males. There from the Parents recognized that martial arts could be a powerful supplement to their children’s education. Hundreds of thousands of kids flocked to martial arts schools. “The Ninja Turtles” and “The Power Rangers” perpetuated that interest. Instructors began to include selfdevelopment programs in their classrooms. This is where we began to lose the adults. In the 1970s, the primary philosophical message was, “Don’t use your martial arts in a fight unless you really have to.” There was an underlying sense that with the privilege of learning martial arts comes responsibility.

Today, instructors who have no more discipline about how they run their lives than the guy driving the Pepsi truck, are demanding from their students everything froma list of good deeds to oaths of good citizenship. While this may be good for the kids, it’s too much for many adults. This is what I call The Eagle Scout Syndrome.” For example, an adult decides to get into shape and learn some self-defense, The martial arts instructor says, “Sure, I’ll teach you self-defense. First, raise your right hhand and swear to this student creed, submit a list of life goals, promise to quit drinking beer, and start helping litte old ladies across the street.” This is a somewhat exaggerated example ofthe Eagle Scout Syndrome. But, the point is simple, Rather than giving the adult what he wants, instructors try to turn him into an eagle scout. Yes, you should have a ‘motivational message ofthe week and be a positive influence on helping someone reach his potential. However, publisher that should not replace sweat and hard work.

If an adult needs therapy, ell go to a therapist. If he wants to learn self-defense, he’ll come to you. His therapist is not qualified to teach self-defense and you aren’t qualified to play pop psychologist, no matter how many Tony Robbins’ tapes you’ve listened to.

Sure, if you’re a dynamic leader and promote positive principles, you will have influence, but don’t put the carriage in front of the horse. Those benefits are a RESULT of the training. They are not THE training. ‘As my baby-boomer friend said, “What is there in a martial arts school for me?” He said he didn’t want to jump through all these hoops just to learn a skill. “Scuba diving is very seriousand probably more dangerous than learning martial arts. But you don’t have to promise to honor your parents to learn how to dive? he argued. ‘The largest market in the country is the baby boomers. Yet, many schools can’t give classes away to this age group. Have the martial arts changed in the last 20 years? A side kick is stil a side kick. Self-defense is still self-defense. The difference is that wwe used to acquire confidence from learning how to defend ourselves. Today, we try to sell confidence instead of self-defense. That’sa creed the baby boomers are simply not buying. JOHN GRADEN Publisher

Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in August 1997.

Cite this article: John Graden, “As I See It: The Eagle Scout Syndrome,” Martial Arts Professional, August 1, 1997, https://www.martialartsprofessional.com/as-i-see-it-the-eagle-scout-syndrome/
Martial arts school owners: make November and December your two best months of 2026 without holiday sales. Get the free book Q4 Extraordinary Results by Stephen Oliver.

John Graden

John Graden wrote for the print edition of Martial Arts Professional. Columns and articles are republished from the magazine archive with their original issue dates.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button