Like a Human, Part One… Make Sure Students And Parents Know You Heard Them!

Most of us talk without connecting. How to hear somebody, and how to make sure they know you heard them.
Most of what happens in a school is a conversation, from the enrollment to the parent who catches you after class. Every one of them takes the same skill… listening so the other person knows you heard them.
You feel connected over a good meal. Watching a movie you both like (or the group likes) together. Going to Disneyland, a sporting event, a Broadway play, or even a team that’s off to a battle. All of those, during and when they’re over, are connecting human experiences.
Why? Because we share and experience the same thing. The more significant the experience, positive like watching the Suns finally win a championship, or dangerous like a battle, the more connecting it can be.
Researchers who studied military veterans, football fans and martial arts students found that people who’d been through something painful together were more likely to fuse with their group (researchers call it identity fusion), where the group starts to feel like part of who they are (Whitehouse et al., 2017). A Yale study found that even eating a piece of chocolate is more intense when somebody next to you is eating the same chocolate at the same time… and it works the same way for unpleasant experiences (Boothby et al., 2014). Sharing it makes it bigger… that’s the bond!
Talking Is Supposed to Connect Us
Now let’s take basic human connection… speaking to each other. While this seems like it’s connecting, a large part of us are talking but not connecting.
How large? A University of Chicago study had people try to get an ambiguous message across to their spouse or close friend, and to a stranger. Everybody assumed the spouse would understand them better. The spouses did no better than the strangers (Savitsky et al., 2011). The closer we are to somebody, the more we tend to assume they got it, so we check less. John Gottman (the University of Washington psychologist who spent decades watching couples argue in his lab, and got famous for predicting which ones would split up from a few minutes of conversation) found that about 69% of the problems couples argue about are perpetual… the same argument, for years, never resolved (Gottman & Silver, 1999).
That’s because the usual communicating experience together is like I was watching a play and you’re watching a basketball game. Instead of taking turns hearing each other, understanding and showing empathy (even if we didn’t agree), it often turns into a battle of whose position is more important.
Princeton researchers put a speaker and a listener in scanners and found that when the listener actually understood, their brain activity started to mirror the speaker’s, sometimes a beat behind and sometimes a beat AHEAD, anticipating. When the listener didn’t understand, the coupling disappeared (Stephens et al., 2010). LITERALLY connecting or… NOT.
I tell people all the time: listen like a human. I mean that we actually listen and hear and make sure they know we heard them. Like we actually are trying to absorb and understand. To treat others like they are human too, with all the frailties, challenges and problems we all share, and that in this moment you’re all about comprehending their experience. We do that through validation.
Validation is: you hear what the other person is saying and make sure they know that you heard it… not by saying “I hear what you’re saying, BUT” (which is just a way to retort). You do it by reflecting, paraphrasing, asking important questions, working to fully understand. This doesn’t mean agreeing, it means making sure they know you understand.
Why We Communicate Badly…
If connecting feels this good and everybody wants it, why do we turn a conversation into a battle? A few reasons, and every one of them happens all the time.
We were taught to talk, not to listen. Nobody gave you a class in reflecting. You got graded on speaking up, having an answer, making your point. Do that for years and talking first becomes the reflex.
Talking about ourselves is rewarding. Literally. A Harvard study found that disclosing your own thoughts and opinions lights up the same reward regions of the brain as food and money, and people would give up money for the chance to talk about themselves (Tamir & Mitchell, 2012). Your turn to talk isn’t just your turn… it’s a treat, and you’re waiting for it.
We think we already understood. Here’s how I put it in my conflict resolution seminars: we’re so busy figuring out our next statement and next retort that we don’t listen. We think we know what someone is saying because we’ve heard it 15 million times. “Okay. I processed that. I understood it. I know exactly what she’s saying.” And then you just barrel ahead without validating what’s going on. The closer the person, the worse this gets (that’s the Chicago study above).
Emotion runs ahead of logic. I often talk about how Vulcans couldn’t exist, because emotion is almost always in front of logic. I WANT my position to win, so I come up with the “logical” reasons to justify it. Once that’s running, the other person’s words are just fuel for my rebuttal.
A button got pushed. If your emotion is out of proportion to the actual event, a button got pushed. Buttons are learned adaptations, usually formed young, and they fire like reflexes. Once a button fires you’re usually defending something that happened years ago, and the person in front of you has no idea. By the way – spouses and family members are really good at pushing them…
Understanding feels like losing. People confuse understanding with agreeing. If I reflect your position accurately, some part of me thinks I just gave it to you. I didn’t. Validation is not agreement (more on that below). People who get this can hear almost anything without getting defensive but if you miss this skill, get ready to always be in adversarial situations.
What Bad Communication Looks Like

“I hear what you’re saying, but…” From my conflict resolution work: the number one phrase people make a mistake with is “I hear what you’re saying, but…” Whenever you say the words “I hear what you’re saying, but,” or “I hear what you’re saying” and then go on to say something else, nobody heard what anybody was saying. It’s just a retort. Pay attention to what happens in your body when it’s said to you… you brace, because you know what’s coming.
The three conflict traps. Most adults run into one of these without knowing it:
- Loud. Buttons get pushed, the volume rises, and the fight ends only when everyone is exhausted. Nothing resolves.
- Silent. One person withdraws. Stops calling, stops showing up, says “I’m fine.” No visible blow-up, and the resentment compounds. This is the most dangerous one in a business because it looks like things are fine until the customer or the employee is already gone.
- Mixed. One escalates while the other withdraws, then they swap.
The Four Horsemen. Gottman’s research found four patterns that predict a relationship ending: criticism (attacking character instead of behavior), contempt (sarcasm, eye-rolling, name-calling… the most corrosive of the four), defensiveness (“it’s not me, it’s you”), and stonewalling (the silent treatment, walking away) (Gottman & Silver, 1999). Every one of them is a way of not hearing the other person.
The sentences that feel like listening and aren’t. These are the everyday versions. People say them may think they’re trying to help or are just riding the wave of their poor skills.
| What you say (trying to help) | What it says to them |
|---|---|
| “I hear what you’re saying, but…” | “Here comes the rebuttal.” |
| “At least…” | “Your feeling is too big for the facts.” |
| “I know exactly how you feel.” | “No you don’t.” |
| “The same thing happened to me…” | “This is about you now.” |
| “It’ll be fine.” | “Stop feeling this.” |
| “Have you tried…?” | “You think I haven’t thought of that?” |
| “Why did you do that?” | “You’re on trial.” |
| “Don’t be upset.” | “Your reaction is wrong.” |
| “Calm down.” | “Your reaction is a problem for me.” |
| “You always… / You never…” | “I’m being scored.” |
About “at least.” I hate this one. “At least you still have your job.” “At least the kids are OK.” Every “at least” says their feeling is too big for the facts (often without you meaning it that way), and it ends the conversation. Brené Brown’s research on empathy makes the same point: an empathic response rarely begins with “at least,” because “at least” is an attempt to put a silver lining on something instead of getting in there with the person (Brown, 2013, 2021). She separates empathy, which is feeling WITH somebody, from sympathy, which is feeling FOR them. “At least” is sympathy. My version: sympathy is the safe distance talking.
One that really hit me hard was when my mom died. I was at the funeral and one of her friends said “at least you got to have fun with her when she was alive!” It’s not that she was wrong… mom was fun (especially at Christmas), smart and cared about all of us, however at the moment what that felt like was “you don’t need to feel bad because ‘you got to have fun with her when she was alive’“. In other words judging that I felt bad. Look, I completely realize she meant well and during times like these it’s tough to figure out what to say. I tell this story to illustrate sympathy vs. empathy. This is a great example of her trying to show sympathy. Empathy would have looked more like: “Losing your mom is hard no matter how old you are” or “There’s nothing I can say that makes this okay. I’m here.” Or even just a hand on the shoulder or a hug, and no words at all.
The Tools
Four jobs, in order: hear and understand, validate (make sure they KNOW you understood), express empathy so it’s felt, and then encourage. Most people (me included) try to do them in the wrong order, or skip straight to the last one.
Hear and Understand
In the Communication chapter of The Life Skills of Leaders we teach the listening continuum (Moody, 2023):
- Ignoring
- Pretend listening
- Selective listening
- Attentive listening
- Empathic listening
Selective listening is where most of us live. You’re listening for the thing you can respond to. Your partner says a bunch of things and you hear the one you disagree with, because that’s the one you have an answer for. It’s habit, and you’ve been rewarded your whole life for having a comeback ready.
Empathic listening, the top of the continuum, means getting inside the other person’s frame of reference before you respond. Carl Rogers built an entire approach to therapy on it and argued it was one of the conditions that lets a person change at all (Rogers, 1957).
Six tools, from the book, with one everyday example run all the way through. A friend says: “I’m so done with my sister.”
- Encourager: nod, wait.
- Reflect: “You’re done with your sister…”
- Paraphrase: “She’s worn you out.”
- Inquiry statement: “I’m wondering what happened this time.”
- Supportive: “I can’t say I blame you. That’s been going on a long time.”
- Advising: “Most people I know in that spot end up setting one rule and sticking to it.”
Advising is LAST. Five moves happen before anybody suggests anything, and by then you know what “done” means. Done with the phone calls? Done with the money? Done being the one who always drives to Mom’s? Three different problems that all sound like “I’m done with my sister.”
1. Minimal encouragers. “Go on…”, “hmm”, a nod, silence. The book lists silence as an encourager, and it may be the one people use least. Why does silence work? Because people fill it. Wait a beat longer than feels comfortable after “I’m done with my sister” and most people keep going. They’ll tell you which kind of done!
2. Reflecting. Say back what they said, in their words. “You’re done with your sister.” That’s it. It sounds too simple, and it does two jobs: it confirms you heard the right thing, and it makes them hear their own sentence. People often realize the sentence didn’t say what they meant (Moody, 2023). “Well, not done exactly, it’s that every time she calls it’s about money…” Now you’re somewhere.
3. Paraphrasing. Condense it into your words. “The money is the part that’s wearing you out.” The book gives three reasons for it: you can interrupt a long story without generating resistance, it lets you guide the conversation, and it lets the other person modify what they first said. In Motivational Interviewing the reflection is the core skill (Miller & Rollnick, 2013), and their working guideline for clinicians is more reflections than questions… about two to one.
4. Inquiry statements. An inquiry statement is a statement that leaves the door open, and for a lot of people it works better than a question. “I wonder how long that’s been building.” “It sounds like something happened this week.” “I’m not sure what the hardest part is.” The book has a device I use all the time: start a list out loud (“There’s the money, the phone calls…”) and then stop talking and let them fill in the rest. Questions can feel like probing, a statement usually doesn’t, and people still answer it.
5. Supporting. “I can’t say I blame you.” “I know it can be hard.” You’re telling them they have a right to feel that way. You don’t have to agree with them, and you don’t have to agree with what they’re about to do.
6. Advising. NOW you suggest something, if they even want a suggestion (ask). Your advice is about the real problem, because you found out what it was.
The questions that get the story. Two things make a question work. It’s a follow-up: a series of studies on conversation found that people who ask more questions are liked more, and follow-up questions were the ones doing the work (Huang et al., 2017). The follow-up is the second question, and it’s the one that PROVES you heard the first answer. It’s open: “Is it the money?” gets a yes or a no and stops. “What’s the part that gets to you?” gets a paragraph, and the paragraph has the real thing in it. One more from counseling training… go easy on “why.” “Why did you say that to her?” sounds like an accusation even when you mean it kindly (Ivey et al., 2018). “What was going on for you when you said it?” gets the same information without the courtroom.
The full toolkit. Counseling training, motivational interviewing, dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), police interview training and hostage negotiation all teach overlapping tools with different names. Here they are sorted by what each one is FOR.
Attending: everything before a word comes out.
| Tool | What it sounds or looks like | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Listening position | Phone down, body turned, eye contact, open posture, lean in a little | Egan’s SOLER (Egan, 2014); our White Belt “listening position” (Moody, 2023) |
| Silence | Three to five seconds of nothing after they stop | Counseling microskills (Ivey et al., 2018) |
| Minimal encouragers | “Go on…”, “hmm”, a nod | Ivey et al. (2018); Moody (2023) |
| Match their pace and volume | If they’re quiet and slow, you’re quiet and slow | FBI negotiation training (Voss & Raz, 2016) |
Following: proving you tracked it.
| Tool | What it sounds like | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Reflecting | Their words back: “You’re done with your sister.” | Rogers & Farson (1957); Moody (2023) |
| Mirroring | Repeat their last one to three words as a question: “…done with her?” | Voss & Raz (2016) |
| Paraphrasing | Your words, shorter: “The money is the part that’s wearing you out.” | Ivey et al. (2018); Moody (2023) |
| Reflection of feeling | Name the emotion under the words: “You sound hurt more than angry.” | Ivey et al. (2018) |
| Complex reflection | Say the part they didn’t say: “And you feel guilty for being done.” | Miller & Rollnick (2013) |
| Double-sided reflection | Hold both halves: “Part of you is done, and part of you can’t stand the idea of cutting her off.” | Miller & Rollnick (2013) |
| Summarizing | Every few minutes, the whole thing in three sentences | Ivey et al. (2018); Miller & Rollnick (2013) |
Asking: getting the whole story.
| Tool | What it sounds like | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Open questions | “What happened?” not “Did it go badly?” | Miller & Rollnick (2013) |
| Inquiry statements | “I wonder what changed.” (a statement, not a question) | Moody (2023) |
| TED prompts | “Tell me about… Explain… Describe…” | UK police PEACE interview model (Milne & Bull, 1999) |
| Calibrated questions | “How” and “what” questions that make them think out loud: “How would I even do that?” “What’s the hardest part?” | Voss & Raz (2016) |
| Report everything | “Tell me the whole thing, even the parts that don’t seem important.” | Cognitive Interview (Fisher & Geiselman, 1992) |
| Avoid “why” | “What was going on for you?” instead of “Why did you do that?” | Ivey et al. (2018) |
Understanding: all the way in before you respond.
| Tool | What it sounds like | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Reflection of meaning | “So what this is really about is being taken for granted.” | Ivey et al. (2018) |
| Interests, not positions | Their position is “I’m cutting her off.” Their interest is “I need to stop being the only one who shows up.” Ask for the interest. | Fisher et al. (2011) |
| Observation, feeling, need | “When she calls about money (observation), you feel used (feeling), because you need it to be a two-way street (need).” | Nonviolent Communication (Rosenberg, 2015) |
| Check your understanding | “Let me make sure I’ve got this…” then summarize, then “Did I miss anything?” | Ivey et al. (2018) |
| The 2:1 rule | Two reflections for every question. If you’re asking more than you’re reflecting, you’re interrogating. | Miller & Rollnick (2013) |
Validate: Make Sure They Know You Understood
This is the step that can’t be skipped. EVER.
Empathy is about validation. The validation skill requires a lot of reflection and paraphrasing on both sides. Before you can resolve anything, everyone needs to be heard. That means both people need to rephrase, reflect what the other person said, and all parties feel comfortable that the other parties understood them. Sometimes this is exceedingly difficult because we’ve been taught to talk, not to listen.
I remember one couple who would just not do this part. They couldn’t reflect what each other said nor hear what the other said. I’ll never forget it. I worked with them on reflecting, listening and tried to practice with them. No luck… Finally, I said “Okay, let’s try it with you and me.”
She had a water bottle in front of her.
I said, “Can you just rephrase what I say? All I want you to try is to repeat exactly what I say… nothing else, OK?” She smiled, agreed and said she was ready.
“I would like you to give me the water bottle. Just repeat that after me. Just say, ‘I’d like you to give me the water bottle.'”
At this point you’d expect someone to reply with “I’d like you to give me the water bottle,” right? I mean how specific could I be?
She said: “Here!” and she handed me the water bottle.
Wow! OK, I tried again… I gave her the bottle back. “Let’s try again, this time, hold on to the water bottle. I’d just like you to say the words just like I am saying now: ‘I’d like you to give me the water bottle.'”
She said, “Here’s the water bottle.” She just handed me the water bottle.
This was going nowhere fast… I had to try something else. “Okay, let me see if you can do it the other way. Would you ask me for my water bottle?” She said, “Would you give me your water bottle?” I said, “Okay. What you’d like is for me to give you my water bottle?” She said, “Yes.”
“Great!! That’s reflecting. Didn’t have to do anything except say back what you said.” “Now let’s give you a turn.” “Now. I’d like you to do exactly what we just did.” Then I said it back to her: “I would like you to give me your water bottle.”
She handed me the water bottle.
It took about 25 minutes for her to reflect one sentence back to me, just with me, let alone her husband. This is a very difficult thing for people. In business it shouldn’t be quite as hard… except it IS.
Reflecting it back, making sure they understand that you’re connected with them… this piece can’t be skipped. They have to hear what they said back to them (you have a variety of tools to use), or they’re never going to feel like you connected or cared. This doesn’t mean you agree or are going to give them what they want! You’re just making sure they are heard. It’s making sure they know: I may disagree, but I understand your position.
This is how it works even in high-level diplomacy. When two countries negotiate a treaty, one side states its proposal, the other side reflects it, and they go back and forth on only the first side’s proposal until it’s fully understood. Then the other side gets a turn. They know that whether they agree or completely disagree, they need to know clearly what the other side is saying.
A real example is Camp David in 1978. Egypt and Israel had fought four wars in thirty years, and their leaders got along so badly that the Americans spent most of the summit meeting with each side separately. The American team used what Roger Fisher calls the one-text procedure: the mediators wrote a single draft, then went to each side and asked what was wrong with it. Each side’s answers went into the next draft, and the next draft went back to both sides. After thirteen days and about twenty-three drafts, the United States had a text it was ready to recommend (Fisher et al., 2011). Neither side had to agree with the other along the way… each side just had to be satisfied the draft got their position right before anyone signed.
Carl Rogers suggested the same rule for any argument in a 1951 talk, later published in On Becoming a Person: each person gets to speak up only after restating the ideas and feelings of the previous speaker accurately, to that speaker’s satisfaction (Rogers, 1961). He said if you actually try it, you’ll probably find it’s one of the hardest things you’ve ever done.
The six levels of validation. DBT training lays validation out as a ladder, easiest to hardest (Linehan, 1997). Most of us (me included, on a bad day) stay at level 1 or 2.
| Level | What it sounds like | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Be there | Eye contact, nodding, not multitasking | “I’m paying attention” |
| 2. Reflect accurately | “You’re worn out by this.” | “I got the words right” |
| 3. Say the unsaid | “You’re probably wondering if you’re a bad sibling for feeling this way.” | “I got the part you didn’t say” |
| 4. Make sense of it from their history | “After the last three years, of course this is where you are.” | “Given your life, this is reasonable” |
| 5. Make sense of it as normal | “Anybody in that spot would be done.” | “You’re not broken” |
| 6. Be real | Drop the technique voice. Talk like a person. “That’s awful. I’d be done too.” | “I’m a human talking to a human” |
Supporting statements from the book live here too: “I can’t say I blame you.” “I know it can be hard.” (Moody, 2023). The labeling move from hostage negotiation… “It sounds like you’re afraid this is going to end badly”… is levels 2 and 3 in one sentence (Voss & Raz, 2016).
This week: pick ONE tool, reflecting, and use it before you say anything about your own side.
Part Two covers how to make empathy land and when encouragement helps.
Common questions
What is validation?
Hearing what the other person said and making sure they know you heard it, by reflecting, paraphrasing and asking until you understand. It isn’t agreement, and you don’t have to give them what they want.
What's wrong with saying "I hear what you're saying, but"?
Once you say “but,” the other person stops hearing the first half and gets ready for the rebuttal, so nobody feels heard.
References
Boothby, E. J., Clark, M. S., & Bargh, J. A. (2014). Shared experiences are amplified. Psychological Science, 25(12), 2209–2216. https://doi.org/10.1177/0956797614551162
Brown, B. (2013, December 10). Brené Brown on empathy [Video]. RSA. https://www.thersa.org/video/shorts/2013/12/Brene-Brown-on-Empathy
Brown, B. (2021). Atlas of the heart: Mapping meaningful connection and the language of human experience. Random House.
Egan, G. (2014). The skilled helper: A problem-management and opportunity-development approach to helping (10th ed.). Brooks/Cole.
Fisher, R. P., & Geiselman, R. E. (1992). Memory-enhancing techniques for investigative interviewing: The cognitive interview. Charles C Thomas.
Fisher, R., Ury, W., & Patton, B. (2011). Getting to yes: Negotiating agreement without giving in (3rd ed.). Penguin.
Gottman, J. M., & Silver, N. (1999). The seven principles for making marriage work. Crown.
Huang, K., Yeomans, M., Brooks, A. W., Minson, J., & Gino, F. (2017). It doesn’t hurt to ask: Question-asking increases liking. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 113(3), 430–452. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspp0000097
Ivey, A. E., Ivey, M. B., & Zalaquett, C. P. (2018). Intentional interviewing and counseling: Facilitating client development in a multicultural society (9th ed.). Cengage.
Linehan, M. M. (1997). Validation and psychotherapy. In A. C. Bohart & L. S. Greenberg (Eds.), Empathy reconsidered: New directions in psychotherapy (pp. 353–392). American Psychological Association. https://doi.org/10.1037/10226-016
Milne, R., & Bull, R. (1999). Investigative interviewing: Psychology and practice. Wiley.
Miller, W. R., & Rollnick, S. (2013). Motivational interviewing: Helping people change (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.
Moody, G. (2023). The life skills of leaders. KarateBuilt. https://a.co/d/06inFWR3
Rogers, C. R. (1957). The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21(2), 95–103. https://doi.org/10.1037/h0045357
Rogers, C. R. (1961). On becoming a person: A therapist’s view of psychotherapy. Houghton Mifflin.
Rogers, C. R., & Farson, R. E. (1957). Active listening. Industrial Relations Center, University of Chicago.
Rosenberg, M. B. (2015). Nonviolent communication: A language of life (3rd ed.). PuddleDancer Press.
Savitsky, K., Keysar, B., Epley, N., Carter, T., & Swanson, A. (2011). The closeness-communication bias: Increased egocentrism among friends versus strangers. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 47(1), 269–273. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jesp.2010.09.005
Stephens, G. J., Silbert, L. J., & Hasson, U. (2010). Speaker–listener neural coupling underlies successful communication. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107(32), 14425–14430. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1008662107
Tamir, D. I., & Mitchell, J. P. (2012). Disclosing information about the self is intrinsically rewarding. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(21), 8038–8043. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1202129109
Voss, C., & Raz, T. (2016). Never split the difference: Negotiating as if your life depended on it. HarperBusiness.
Whitehouse, H., Jong, J., Buhrmester, M. D., Gómez, Á., Bastian, B., Kavanagh, C. M., Newson, M., Matthews, M., Lanman, J. A., McKay, R., & Gavrilets, S. (2017). The evolution of extreme cooperation via shared dysphoric experiences. Scientific Reports, 7, Article 44292. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep44292
A version of this article first appeared at mastermoody.com.



