Square Off: Should You Encourage Your Students to Compete in Tournaments?

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, February 1997, in “Square Off” (pages 20–22). See the full issue.
I N ION Q. Should you encourage your students to compete in tournaments? PRO-TOURNAMENT EXEL Renn port karate is a very important entity to offer in any studio! It has always been a major part of my 23 years asa competitor, official, promoter and sport-karate organization head. While most students don’t compete, each school should offer sport karate classes and have a tournament team, By diversifying your school in this way, no student should be Students gain much knowledge from competing — increased self-confidence is the major one. Most cities offer only team sports and some kids are just not good enough to play. Conversely, sport karate is an individual effort; everyone can play. Besides children, it is.a great sport for adults. It is also exciting to travel to different events for many children and adults alike. While some events are not run very well, there are some very well organized, safe events with fair judging, etc., such as in the NASKA (North American Sport Karate Association) and KRANE (Karate Referees Association of New England) organizations. In myarea, greater Boston and Northern New England, 75% of the studios do not participate in sport karate! Why? Here are a few reasons: 1. They may not teach sport karate. . They feel their students are not good enough to compete against the level of competition out there. Many consulting and/or billing companies advise their schools not to go to open tournaments because they should not encourage students to spend any money on martial arts except in their own school. (This I totally disagree with, but itis very true.) 4. Instructors will not allow their students and parents to view quality martial arts at tournaments simply because they are teaching sub-quality martial arts — and risk students/parents putting them on the spot by asking embarrassing questions! Lastly, the important thing to remember is that martial arts and the tournaments were very close in nature in the 1960s, ’70s and even in half of the ’80s. By thisImean that more traditional forms were used and the fighting was much harder. Now, in the “90s, the sport and the art have moved very far apart as two separate entities. Training for the sport is considered separate from the art Instructors need to realize that big changes have been — and will be — made, all for the better. Tony Cogliandro, a 6th-degree black belt in American kenpo (Parker) karate, is president ofthe Krane World Ratings and presi dent ofAmerican Kenpo International with over 50 schools world~ wide. He is also president of Tony Cogliandro’s Kenpo Karate Studio chain in Massachusetts. He has promoted the Boston International Karate Championships since 1980. What do you ANTI-TOURNAMENT Ep g.Ciogo fter competing in state, national and © world-championship martial arts tournaments, one may assume that I would encourage my students to compete. No way. The first reason I don’t recommend tournament participation is that some students base their self-esteem on the results of competition. Just as you are making progress with a student in developing his confidence, you roll the dice and Sen an event that you know is usually a bad experience. Ifhe loses or is cheated, he may place blame upon himself, his instructor or other circumstances. It makes my job much harder. um off to Many students do not possess “unconditional self-esteem.” Next is the threat of injury. Tournament contact rules are not always enforced consistently ring-to-ring. I’ve seen too many splattered noses and cracked ribs to risk that for my students, Beginning and intermediate students are seldom ready for that intense level of contact. Especially when they read in the rule book that,“No face contact and moderate body contact will be enforced,” and it isn’t. ‘ve had students miss months of class due to a tournament injury, and some never came back to class. That’s why we only encourage in-house tournaments. We have much more control over the event and the enforcement of rules. We try to teach students and parents that everything we do in artial arts is based on courtesy and respect. At our in-house events, we can maintain a standard of martial arts etiquette. Yet, time after time at open tournaments, I’ve witnessed adults yelling at kids; competitors cursing at judges; parents fighting with other parents; etc.
Although, I’m sure there were many fine examples of respect throughout the day, the bad examples stand out in my mind and that of my students and families. It’s embarrassing having to explain to a student why an adult black belt acted like a spoiled child, That behavior also can be disillusioning to a student who upheld and believed in the black belt ideals that we teach. Finally, tournament entry fees equal about one-half of your school’s tuition. Add in traveling expenses and you may have several months worth of tuition leaving your school. Many students havea limited budget for martial arts. [want to make sure they are getting the most return for their investment. That return comes in my classroom, where it’s safe and the only temper tantrums are being thrown by the two-year-olds in the viewing area. m A former world champion, Kathy Marlor won the 1991 World Open Tae Kwon Do Championships in Liecester, England; the 1990 silver medal in light-contact sparring at the WAKO World Championships in Venice, Italy; and was a 1990 WAKO National Light-Contact Champion. Sh ¢ owner of USA Karate in Su. Petersburg, Florida. ite C&D, St. Petersburg, FL 33703
MARTIAL ARTS PROFESSIONAL FEBRUARY
Below is a list of motivating needs and actions that ignite people to action. An asterisk is placed beside those that are usually manipulative, and therefore negative, motivators:
Achievement Happiness i Harmony Hatred Information Involvement Learning love “Money Notoriety Belonging Order *Betrayal Peace Camaraderie —_*Politics Challenge Power Change Praise Closure Prestige Compassion __*Rebellion Confidence Consistency ‘Redemption Construction Respect *Control Responsibility Cooperation _—_—Resolution ‘Creation Retention: *Deception “Revenge Decisiveness Security Defense Self-Improvement “Desperation _Self-Worth Education *Ego Enjoyment Esteem Stress Relief Excitement Support Fairness Time *Fear Trust Forgiveness Unity Freedom *Vanity Giving Victory *Greed Vision Students have varie to bean av Intrinsic Vs. Extrinsic Reward There are two classes of rewards that moti vate people to act: intrinsic rewards and extrinsic rewards, Intrinsic rewards are the intangible feelings we have that motivate us, like happiness, recognition, fulfillment, love understanding, peace and acceptance. Intrinsic rewards are the most fulfilling and powerful for long-term motivation. They are also the most difficult to bring about because they require an active investment of emotional energy.
Extrinsic rewards are tangible materials that motivate us including money, awards, romotions and gifts. Extrinsic rewards are easy to give and are powerful short-term mo: tivators. The drawback is that they become addictive, Once you are motivated by an external reward for an action, you expect it the next time you perform the same action, And worse, as the novelty wears off, you may be gin to expect more rewards for the same amount of effort.
Conditioned Response
Motivation is often the result of social conditioning and experience. Most adults are motivated to work for money because they know it can be exchanged for material possessions that they value. The paper itself is ally different from other paper, but we are conditioned to value money and learn to become motivated by it If you want to test this theory, give a ten. dollar bill to a one-year-old and she will probably rip it to pieces for the fun of it. Give it to a seven-year-old and she will be off to the toy store.
Motivation also can be negatively ingrained through experience. We tend to transfer experiences of failure from one area of our life to another, A young man who has experienced failure in successive jobs may be averse to going back to school for more training, assuming this too might fail Although his lack of training might be the reason for his job failure, he resists getting the education he needs because he associates all work-related tasks with failure. nota Theories of Motivation There are several accepted theories of motivation. While this book is not a scholarly text that subscribes to any one theory, understanding the background of motivation theory can help you apply the ideas presented in the following chapters, The Behavioral Theory, probably the
FEBRUARY “97 MARTLA ARTS PROFESSIONAL most commonly known motivational theory (everyone who has ever taken a high-school psychology course is familiar with Pavlov’s salivating dogs), states that desired behaviors recur when reinforced and that people can be influenced to behave like others whom they see rewarded for such behavior. According to the Behavioral Theory, one person can motivate another person simply by rewarding desirable behavior and punish ing or ignoring undesirable behavior. While we all know that this works for training pets, humans are more complicated. Humans have varied needs and desires and what one person perceives to be a reward may not have any effect on another. And there is always the risk that the desired behavior, once established, will disappear once the rewards cea The Cognitive Theory suggests that people are most motivated by things that pique their curiosity and are interesting or fun, This theory relies heavily on intrinsic motivation and the desire ofthe individual to answer a question, fulfill a need, or achieve competency in a subject. It does not, however, account for the reasons that people endure intense or prolonged suffering (ncither interesting nor fun) to achieve a The Humanistic View is based on Abraham Maslow’s idea that people have a fundamental drive to fulfill certain needs ina specific order. The basic human needs, according to the theory, are physiological satiation, safety, belonging, esteem, selfactualization, understanding, and aesthetic. As a level of need is quenched, a new level is approached and the quest to satisfy begins anew, The Achievement Theory states that people develop a need for achievement and seek to fulfill that need while avoid. ing the possibility of failure. While each theory has merits and applies in many real-life cases, a blanket theory to motivate people in every situ tion is elusive. The sheer number and complexity of variables involved in moti vation defy a “perfect answer” or “magic technique.” Motivation depends upon having an understanding of people and their wants and needs.
Al times, the line between motivating and manipulating may seem to blur. When does the positive action of motivating become the negative action of manipulating? Manipulation is the act of deceiving someone into doing something he might not otherwise do, Motivation is the act of encouraging someone to do something he needs to do, but may not be able to initiate or complete on his own. When you motivate someone to do something, you build on his latent intrinsic desire to do it. When you manipulate a person into doing something, you create a false desire to do it. Asan example, imagine a baseball team, The coach of the team is aware that one of his average players has the potential to be a much better player, but is not applying himself to the game. Although the player is always on time for practice and follows instructions, he does not have the emotional commitment = necessary to use his fall potential. Of course, he wants to play better, but he is not sure how to improve his game. ‘To motivate the player, the coach gives him a few performance goals to meet in practice, promising hima spot in the starting line-up if he can meet the goals within four weeks. This is an example of motivation. The player wants to improve and the coach provides him with the necessary direction and rewards to spur him on. On the other hand, consider another team where the coach is not as caring. Instead, he has personal vendetta against his star outfielder. They have never gotten along and the coach is anxious to be rid of him. The coach approaches an average player and mentions that if he works little harder, he could have the star outfielder’s position. He also mentions, deceitfully, that the star outfielder has made unkind remarks about the player behind his back. This makes the second-string player angry and vindictive toward the star player. He begins to play little tricks on the star, hiding his equipment, making him late to practice, starting rumors about him, and generally distracting the outfielder from his game. When the star’s performance becomes erratic, the coach seizes the opportunity to replace him with the second-string player, his intention from the beginning. ‘As you can see, manipulation is an unintelligent and negative form of motivation. Eventually, both players will figure out what the coach has done to them and turn against him. Consequently, manipulation is a very short-term answer. It might make the situation better for a short time after which things will get considerably worse.
When motivating yourself or others, itis best to avoid the manipulative motivators [see sidebar lis; negatives are designated with an asterisk}, since the results generally will be short-term and the problem will resurface when the initial motivation disappears. Consider a real-life scenario in which the motivators are all negative. You workina large manufacturing company and discover that a long-time rival has applied for a supervisory position in your department. Not wanting to see him advance ahead of you, you decide to apply for the position as well. Although you have little interest in the pi sition, you are notparticularly happy with your current job and do not want to be at the mercy of your contemptible colleague. You are offered the job and accept it, but in a few weeks your rival finds a better job at another company and leaves your department.
You suddenly realize that your job is no longer gratifying, now that your rival snot there to see your success. In fact, you now feel just as unhappy and empty as you did in your previous position. The reason? In short, your motives in applying for the new job were not related to your long-term success, rather to short-term vengeance against someone else. When your rival fled the scene, so did your motivation, leaving you with the same lamentable feelings with which you started.
Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in February 1997.



