As I See It: Isn’t It Time for an Alternate Choice in Attire?

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, September 1998, in “As I See It” (page 4). See the full issue.
A local aerobics studio owner and T had lunch recently. Her studio is next to a karate school. She has over 500 women active in the studio; the karate school has 70 active kids and 10 adults. She and three of her students were looking through the window of the karate school one evening after class. One of the girls said, “That looks interesting. Maybe we could do that.” Another girl shot back, “Yeah, but look at what we’d have to wear.” That was it. End of subject. The prospect of wearing a gi was so unattractive they wouldn’t consider it, despite their interest. Here’s a challenge. Without using the word “tradition,” can anyone explain why we require that our students wear a karate gi (or kungfu uniform)? Sure, when you’re practicing kata, the long sleeves absorb a little shock. That’s the best possible answer I can come up with unless you are grappling, The rest of the answers have to do with some sort of illusion of control. There’s this myth in martial arts that students are incapable of learning unless the instructor controls how they dress, act, demonstrate respect, maintain eye-contact or breathe. I just don’t know how ski, golf, dance, or college professors are able to teach their students anything without that level of control.
The gi is unattractive, restraining and funny looking to most people. Why, then, has it not been replaced with something more practical and attractive? Sure, the revolution of colored uniforms in the ‘70s was interesting. Until we started seeing tie-dyed gis and gis with capes. At that point, we were even more silly looking to the Nike-wearing public. We know that adults, particularly women, are very conscious of how they look, Forcing them to wear an outfit that makes them look 20 pounds heavier because it’s tradition, has proven to be a sure-fire method of turning that market away. Not only do most adults consider the gi unattractive on them, but typically, the new student’s uniform is the ugliest in the school. New students are forced to wear an outfit that looks like a poorly cut pair of pajamas. The gi usually still has folds in it from being in the bag, and the stiff belt is sticking straight out.
Consider this indisputable fact: The number-one fear for adults is the fear of being embarrassed. Yet, the gi seems designed to re-create those same kind of sick feelings from back in high school when you knew you just didn’t fit in. Would you rather help 20 adults benefit from the martial arts in uniform, or 100 adults wearing workout clothes they are comfortable in? Personally, P’d go for the 100. I know what good martial arts training can do for someone. I won’t let something as silly as a “traditional uniform” stand in the way. I know that many of us were taught that the uniform represented a “stripping of the material stature of the student.” Whether students arrived in a Rolls Royce or on their skateboards, they shared the same status in the eyes of the almighty sensei. Of course, sensei was wearing a nice uni Americans are not attracted to having to completely subordinate themselves in order to learn a skill. In America, we’te taught “Personal Power,” rather than, “Collective Subordination.” Subordination, while fine for other societies, is contrary to the American spirit. Americans prefer to stand out, be seen, feel important. Our background, values, and situation are drastically different from the Eastern roots of the martial arts. What was important to our Asian instructors generations ago is not always relevant in today’s world. I’m not suggesting that replacing the uniform with fitness attire is the complete answer to attracting adults. It’s just part of the answer. The uniform is much more of a personal preference than an important tradition. After 30 years of progress in American martial arts, it’s time for an alternate choice of attire if we have any hope of attracting a larger adult student base into our schools. # rm.
Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in September 1998.



