Columnists

As I See It: What Condition Is Your Tradition In?

From the archive. Originally published in Martial Arts Professional, December 1997, in “As I See It” (page 4). See the full issue.

HSL SEE IT letter Your Tradition In? wo martial arts school owners were debating 4an issue in a recent exchange. The first martial artist lambasted the other for suggesting curriculum and ranks could be altered without sacrificing student quality, “Give me tradition any day!” he scoffed.

As publisher of thismagazine, I can tell you this is a response that I’ve heard more times than I care to say, Its often followed by the implication that the innovator is motivated by greed rather than the simple desire to improve. In the school I was raised in, innovation was the tradition. Though we had a taekwondo base, my instructor adapted the deeper balances and sharper lines of shotokan karate into our forms. He felt the design of the Korean form was great, but the balances could be deeper to work the legs more. He also ‘made minor changes to theforms to make them more exciting. Ourpunching style evolved more from boxing than from an Eastern art. Westill, however, called our style “taekwondo.” This way oftraining was our tradition. from the Ican also state without question, my instructor was not innovating in order to make more money or increase retention. He hated the business side of martial arts. He innovated because he loved the martial artsand wanted what he learned reflected in his teachings. As he learned more, the program evolved. It was not about money.

Just because someone who practices your style operates in a manner different from your tradition doesn’t mean that person is just out for a buck. Maybe the way he was raised in the arts is different than the way you were.

Not only can people from the same style have different traditions, but people within a single schoolcan also have different traditions. For instance, maybe in your school your students always wore white uniforms and had to learn three forms for the first belt, which typically takes six months to earn, That’s the tradition your students are coming up under.

However, say you decided to make a change and allow students to wear t-shirts, and divide that six month belt into three two-month belts with just one form each. Then the new students would come up under different tradition. Isit better or worse than the old way? Does it matter? No. All that matters is the quality of the black belts they eventually become. As a local Korean 8th-degree once said to me once, “There are a lot of ways to get to New York. The most important thing is that you get there’ To me, getting there means producing quality black belts who can defend themselves, are in good publisher shape and who demonstrate the qualities of respect and courtesy inherent in a good program. I’ve tried to make that my tradition. The process—curriculum, techniques, ranking, clothing, etc—that| use to achieve that goal will always change Just because someone adjusts his curriculum doesn’t make him a greedy con man. Maybe that’s just the way he likes to train. It doesn’t make him any less of a martial artist asa result.

Tthink it’s important to evaluate how tradition should serve us and our students. Some traditions serve us better than others. Some simply getin the way of what really counts. For instance, I’ve long felt the karate gi is an outdated, ugly outfit that many adults, particularly women, are not going to wear in order to train. [think the gi is cumbersome, restricting and kind of silly looking on most beginners. Many would view my opinion as selling out when, in fact, money has nothing to do with it.I simply don’t like to train in a gi. When [ train, it’s in a t-shirt. It’s more comfortable. And that’s been my tradition. Still, whenever I visit a school that requests I wear a uniform instead of a t-shirt, I’m always respect ful and comply. After all, respect is a very good tradition. But, if the ‘owner listens closely he may hear me grumble under my breath—as I try to get the strings on the ends of the gi top to stay tied “Give me tradition any day”

Text recovered from a scanned print copy; passages printed over photographs or beside advertising could not be recovered and are omitted, so read the full issue for the complete layout. Reproduced from the print edition. Prices, programs, events, titles and contact details are as they stood in December 1997.

Cite this article: John Graden, “As I See It: What Condition Is Your Tradition In?,” Martial Arts Professional, December 1, 1997, https://www.martialartsprofessional.com/as-i-see-it-what-condition-is-your-tradition-in/
Martial arts school owners: make November and December your two best months of 2026 without holiday sales. Get the free book Q4 Extraordinary Results by Stephen Oliver.

John Graden

John Graden wrote for the print edition of Martial Arts Professional. Columns and articles are republished from the magazine archive with their original issue dates.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Back to top button